Looking for the best places to eat in downtown New Braunfels? Whether you’re a local or just passing through, downtown New Braunfels offers a vibrant food scene with a variety of options, from upscale dining to casual bites. Let’s dive into the top five must-try best restaurants to eat in downtown New Braunfels that will make your taste buds dance.
1. McAdoo’s Seafood Company
If you’re craving fresh seafood with a Texas twist, McAdoo’s Seafood Company is a must. Housed in the beautifully restored 1915 New Braunfels post office, this elegant spot serves up oysters, shrimp, and fish dishes that highlight the Gulf Coast’s finest catches. McAdoo’s is indeed one of the best restaurants in downtown New Braunfels, with their charming patio being the perfect place to enjoy an upscale meal in the heart of New Braunfels. Wondering where to eat in New Braunfels for seafood? McAdoo’s is the answer.
Kelsey’s Tip: My personal favorite is the seafood fondue- it may clog your arteries but butter, cream, cheese and seafood never tasted so good! I love getting this on my birthday with a slice of their insanely good key lime pie!
2. Huisache Grill
For a cozy yet refined dining experience, head over to Huisache Grill. This local favorite is one of Hank’s and my favorite date night spots. They offer a diverse menu of New American cuisine, with everything from juicy steaks to flavorful salads and pasta dishes. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the art is always on point and changing. As one of the best restaurants in downtown New Braunfels, it is perfect for a romantic night out.
Fun fact: I worked at Huisache as a hostess in high school and ate their chicken tortilla soup and rolls nearly every day (for free!) and I still haven’t tired of their food.
Kelsey’s Tip: The Grilled Quail with Jalapeño Bacon Glaze is always a hit but honestly, everything on the menu is amazing!
3. Cody’s Restaurant and Bar
Who said New Braunfels didn’t have upscale eateries?? They haven’t been to Cody’s.
Looking for a stylish spot where to eat in New Braunfels and enjoy craft cocktails and modern cuisine? Cody’s is the place to be. Known for its upscale American fare, Cody’s offers creative dishes using seasonal, fresh ingredients. With a sleek interior and outdoor seating, it’s ideal for both a casual lunch and an elegant dinner. It’s another excellent choice for those seeking the best restaurants in downtown New Braunfels.
Kelsey’s Tip: Try the Seared Scallops with Sweet Corn Risotto – it’s unforgettable! And honestly, making risotto is a pain so you should always order it at restaurants.
4. Alpine Haus Restaurant
If you’re in the mood for authentic German cuisine, Alpine Haus is where it’s at. Located in a quaint, historic house, this restaurant offers hearty German classics like schnitzel, sausages, and potato pancakes. The cozy atmosphere and traditional recipes make it a standout spot in a town known for its German heritage. It’s undoubtedly one of the best restaurants in downtown New Braunfels.
Kelsey’s Tip: You can’t go wrong with their Jägerschnitzel and a side of red cabbage. They also have a stellar beer menu so do yourself a favor and enjoy an imported beer with your meal.
5. Muck & Fuss
For gourmet burgers and craft beer lovers, Muck & Fuss is a must-visit in downtown New Braunfels. This casual yet trendy spot serves up juicy, inventive burgers along with a great selection of local beers on tap. The industrial-chic atmosphere and friendly vibe make it a favorite for families and groups. If you are wondering where to eat in New Braunfels for burgers, Muck & Fuss is the perfect choice and ranks among the best restaurants in downtown New Braunfels.
Kelsey’s Tip: Make the burger into a salad so you can enjoy more truffle garlic fries and have a boozy milkshake for dessert.. You’ll thank me later!
6. Bootleggers Pizza Parlor
Craving pizza? Bootleggers is a local gem that delivers creative, artisan pizzas in a fun, laid-back setting. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing a pie to go, this spot offers a variety of toppings and crust options, from classic margherita to more unique combinations like the BBQ Chicken Pizza. It stands out as one of the best restaurants in downtown New Braunfels for pizza lovers.
Kelsey’s Tip: This place has strong ‘local favorite’ vibes and is a great choice for grown ups and kids. They have pool tables, arcade games and a playground for the kids out back. This is a great option for family night. Don’t skip the garlic knots as an app!
